Before you start
- Crawl the current site and export every URL, title and meta description.
- Export top pages and queries from Google Search Console (last 12 months).
- List pages with backlinks — those must keep their value.
- Record current rankings and conversions as a baseline.
- Save a full backup of the old site, including the database and media files.
- Note any tracking you rely on: analytics, call tracking numbers, ad conversion tags.
Tools like Screaming Frog (free up to a limit) or a site audit tool can handle the crawl. Don’t skip the baseline — without it, you won’t be able to tell a real problem from normal fluctuation after launch.
Map every URL
Create a spreadsheet: old URL → new URL. Keep URLs the same where you can. Where they change, plan a 301 redirect to the closest equivalent page — never redirect everything to the homepage.
| Old URL | New URL | Action |
|---|---|---|
| /services/ac-repair.html | /ac-repair/ | 301 redirect |
| /about-us/ | /about-us/ | Keep as is |
| /2019-spring-special/ | /maintenance-plans/ | 301 to closest page |
| /test-page-2/ | — | Let it 404 or 410 (no value) |
Prioritize pages that get traffic, rank for valuable terms or have backlinks. Low-value pages with no traffic and no links can be removed, but make that a deliberate decision, not an accident.
During the build
- Keep (and improve) content that ranks. Don’t cut text just for design.
- Carry over titles, headings and internal links for important pages.
- Block the staging site from search engines.
- Keep structured data (LocalBusiness, FAQ, reviews where valid) or add it if it was missing.
- Check image alt text, file names and compression for new images.
- Make sure the new templates are fast on mobile — a redesign is the perfect time to fix speed.
Watch out for design-driven content cuts. A designer may want a short, clean service page. If the old page had 900 words and ranked well, cutting it to 150 can cost you that ranking. Use design to make long content readable — headings, lists, tables, FAQs — instead of deleting it.
Launch day
- Remove staging noindex and check robots.txt.
- Upload redirects and test a sample of old URLs.
- Submit the new XML sitemap in Search Console.
- Check analytics, call tracking and forms.
- Confirm HTTPS works everywhere and old HTTP and www/non-www versions redirect correctly.
- Crawl the new site to catch broken internal links and missing titles.
- Update the website link in your Google Business Profile if URLs changed.
Launch early in the week, not on a Friday afternoon. If something breaks, you want people available to fix it.
After launch
Watch Search Console for 404s and coverage issues daily for the first two weeks, then weekly. Small dips are normal; a proper plan means they recover quickly.
- Days 1–3: test forms and calls again, review crawl errors, fix any missed redirects.
- Weeks 1–2: check indexing in Search Console and compare top pages against your baseline.
- Weeks 3–8: compare rankings, traffic and leads. Investigate any key page that drops and stays down.
- Month 3: once things stabilize, start improving pages further — the new site is a better platform to grow from.
WordPress-specific checks
Most small-business redesigns I see are WordPress-to-WordPress or a move from a builder like Wix or Squarespace to WordPress. Each has its own traps.
| Area | What to check |
|---|---|
| Reading settings | “Discourage search engines” is unchecked on the live site |
| Permalinks | URL structure matches your map (with or without trailing slashes, categories in URLs) |
| SEO plugin | Titles, meta descriptions and noindex settings migrated correctly |
| Redirects | Managed in one place — a plugin or the server, not both |
| Media | Image URLs still work; old attachment pages don’t create thin indexed pages |
| Blog | Categories, tags and author archives either useful or set to noindex |
| Forms | Notifications go to the right inbox; spam protection works |
Moving from a hosted builder adds one more step: those platforms often use their own URL patterns, such as product or blog prefixes. Export the full list of old URLs before you cancel the old plan — once the account is closed, recovering that list is much harder.
Also plan who does what. On a typical small project, the developer handles the build and redirects, the SEO side handles the crawl, mapping and monitoring, and the business owner signs off on content and tests forms and calls. If one person covers several roles, write the checklist down anyway. Launch days go wrong when everyone assumes someone else checked the robots.txt file.
Mistakes that sink rankings
- Leaving “discourage search engines” on. One checkbox in WordPress can hide the whole site.
- Redirecting everything to the homepage. Google may treat these as soft 404s, and the page-level value is lost.
- Changing domains and URLs and content all at once without a plan. Each change adds risk; do them together only with a careful map.
- Removing location or service pages because they “look repetitive.” If they ranked, keep or improve them.
- Forgetting tracking. Without call and form tracking, you can’t judge whether the new site performs better.
Done carefully, a redesign usually ends up improving visibility over time, though no one can promise rankings won’t move at all in the short term. If you’re planning one, see how I handle redesigns and my technical SEO work — or send me your current site and I’ll tell you where the risks are.


