iiDusanDeveloper · Designer · SEO Taking 2 new clients Let's talk
Guides

How to Choose a Web Designer for Your Small Business: 12 Questions to Ask

How to Choose a Web Designer for Your Small Business: 12 Questions to Ask
In short: a good-looking portfolio isn’t enough. Before you hire, ask about ownership, SEO at launch, speed, content, lead tracking and post-launch support — and get a fixed, written scope. The answers will tell you more than any design mockup.

Why this matters

Many business owners pay for a website twice: once for a site that looks nice, and again for one that actually works. A few questions up front can save months and thousands of dollars.

The problem isn’t usually bad intentions. Web design is a broad field: some designers are great at visuals but know little about SEO; some developers write excellent code but have never built a site meant to generate phone calls. You need to find out which kind of provider you’re talking to before you sign.

12 questions to ask

  1. Can I see sites you built for businesses like mine?
  2. Who will I actually work with day to day?
  3. Will I own the domain, hosting, content and code?
  4. Is the design custom or a template?
  5. How is SEO handled at launch?
  6. How fast will the site load on mobile?
  7. Who writes the content?
  8. Can I edit the site myself?
  9. How do you track calls and leads?
  10. What happens to my rankings if this is a redesign?
  11. What does support cost after launch?
  12. Is the price fixed, and what’s not included?

What good answers sound like

Asking is only half of it. Here’s roughly what you want to hear — and what should make you pause.

Question Good sign Warning sign
Examples Live sites in your industry or similar businesses Only mockups or screenshots
Ownership Domain and hosting in your name; you get all logins “We keep it on our platform”
SEO at launch Specific list: titles, schema, sitemap, Search Console, redirects “SEO is a separate service later”
Speed Clear targets and how they’ll be tested on mobile “It’ll be fast”
Content A plan for who writes what, with deadlines “Just send us text when you have it”
Lead tracking Call tracking and form tracking set up and tested Only “we’ll install analytics”
Redesign URL mapping and 301 redirects described Blank look or “Google figures it out”
Price Fixed quote with exclusions listed Hourly with no estimate

Pay special attention to the content question. Content is where most projects stall. If neither side clearly owns it, the site sits unfinished for months — or launches with placeholder text. If the designer writes content, ask whether they’ll interview you about your services, customers and service area, because generic copy won’t rank or convert.

On editing: you should be able to change phone numbers, hours, photos and simple text without calling anyone. On redesigns: if you already rank, the provider should talk about protecting that before you ask. My redesign SEO checklist covers what that involves.

Comparing proposals

When you have two or three quotes, don’t just compare totals. Put them side by side and check:

  • Page count and page list. Ten pages with real service and area pages is a different product from five generic pages.
  • What’s included at launch versus what’s an add-on.
  • Timeline and milestones, including when you’ll see a first design.
  • Revision rounds and what counts as a change request.
  • First-year total cost, including hosting, maintenance and software.
  • Payment terms. A deposit with milestone payments is normal; 100% up front is a risk for you.

Call one or two of their past clients if you can. Ask whether the project ran on time, whether the site brings in leads, and whether the provider still answers the phone.

After you hire: your part

Even the best designer can’t build a great site alone. Projects run faster and turn out better when the business owner is prepared. Before kickoff, gather:

  • Logins for your domain registrar, current hosting, Google Business Profile, Search Console and analytics — or at least know who has them.
  • A list of services in order of importance to your revenue, and the towns or neighborhoods you actually want work from.
  • Real photos of your team, vehicles, office and finished jobs. Phone photos are fine if they’re sharp and well lit.
  • Licenses, certifications, warranties and awards you can show.
  • Three competitor or industry sites you like — and what you like about them.
  • Customer questions you hear every week. They become FAQ sections and service-page content.

Pick one decision-maker on your side. When feedback comes from three partners and a spouse, projects stall and designs end up as compromises nobody loves. Set aside time each week to review drafts and reply within a couple of days — slow feedback is the most common reason small-business sites launch late.

Finally, agree up front on what “done” means: which pages are live, which tracking is tested, what training you’ll receive and how long support lasts after launch.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed #1 rankings.
  • You don’t own the site or can’t leave without losing it.
  • No real examples in your industry.
  • Vague pricing or “we’ll see” timelines.
  • No written contract or scope of work.
  • Pressure to decide today because of a “limited-time” discount.
  • They can’t explain in plain English how the site will bring you customers.

Any one of these is worth a follow-up question. Two or three together usually mean you should keep looking.

You can see my typical packages on the pricing page and finished projects in my work. Want my answers to all twelve? Ask me — or read how I work.

d
Dusan Miladinovic

Founder of iDusan — web developer, designer and SEO specialist with 15+ years of experience and 400+ websites built. More about me.

Let's get you more leads.

Free audit of your website and your top local competitors. Reply within 24 hours — no pressure, no sales pitch.